208 Supreme
$24Our most-loaded pie and the local favorite — marinara, house cheese, pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onion, olive & mushroom in every bite.
The Menu · Island Park, Idaho
Island Park Pizza Menu
Bold signature pies, build-your-own, fresh salads and dessert pizzas — all on dough we make fresh every single day, right here on US-20.
Everything at Blue Buffalo Pizzeria starts the same way: dough made fresh in-house every day, hand-stretched, topped with marinara and our house cheese blend, and baked to a golden, blistered crust. It's some of the best pizza in Island Park — the kind of meal worth pulling off US-20 for, whether you're heading into Yellowstone's West Entrance or winding down after a day on the water.
Below is our full menu with current prices. Ready to eat? Order online for pickup, call (208) 558-8046, or plan your visit and dine in with us.
Signature Pizzas
The Ones People Drive In For
Nine house pizzas, each built to be shared around a warm table. Every one starts with marinara and house cheese unless noted.
Mad Hawaiian
$20Sweet heat done right: Canadian bacon and pineapple with a kick of jalapeño over marinara and house cheese.
Meat Eater
$23Four meats for the serious carnivore — pepperoni, bacon, sausage & Canadian bacon piled high.
Before You Come In
Plan the Rest of Your Visit
Find our hours, directions and parking on the Visit page, or read our family story and how we make the dough fresh every day.