Our Story · Island Park, Idaho

The Family Behind Blue Buffalo Pizzeria

A family-run pizzeria built for gathering — where the dough is made fresh daily and every pizza is meant to be shared.

Friends sharing pizzas around a table at Blue Buffalo Pizzeria in Island Park, Idaho

Family-Run · At Blue Buffalo Resort

Built for the Moment the Day Winds Down

Blue Buffalo Pizzeria is a family-run spot tucked into Blue Buffalo Resort on the edge of Island Park, Idaho. We opened for the moment the day's adventures wind down — after the trail, the lake, the sled run, or the long drive in from Yellowstone's West Entrance — when what you really want is a hot pizza and a warm table with the people you traveled here with.

As part of Blue Buffalo Resort's cabins on US-20, we see the same faces come through season after season: anglers, families, snowmobilers, and travelers on their way to the park. Being one of the few sit-down spots for pizza in Island Park is something we take seriously — for a lot of folks, this is dinner after a big day, and we want to get it right.

How It's Made

Dough Made Fresh, Every Single Day

No shortcuts and no day-old shortcuts in a bag — we mix, proof, and hand-stretch our dough in-house so every crust comes out golden and blistered.

The Craft

From Fresh Dough to Your Table

Every pizza follows the same four steps — the reason our regulars keep coming back.

  1. Fresh Dough

    Made from scratch daily and hand-stretched to order — never frozen, never pre-pressed.

  2. Hand-Built

    Marinara and our house cheese blend, then quality toppings loaded on by hand.

  3. Baked Golden

    Baked hot until the crust blisters and the cheese pulls just right.

  4. Boxed or Served

    Sliced and brought to your table, or boxed hot and ready for the road.

The Welcome

Friendly Faces & a Table to Gather Around

The best thing our guests tell us isn't about the pizza — it's about the welcome. Our team greets road-trippers and resort guests like regulars, and takes care of big groups without breaking a sweat. It's the kind of place where a whole table can agree on dinner, from a classic pepperoni to the surprisingly addictive Pickle Pizza.

Good pizza, big windows, mountain views, and people who are genuinely glad you stopped in — that's what a family pizzeria in Island Park should feel like. Pull up a chair.

Explore the Menu Plan your visit →
Friends slicing a fresh pizza around the table at Blue Buffalo Pizzeria

Come Say Hi

Pull Up a Chair

Staying at the resort or just passing through Island Park? Order online or call ahead and we'll have your pizza hot and ready.

Order Online Call (208) 558-8046