Island Park, Idaho · Minutes from Yellowstone

Hand-Crafted Pizza
in the Heart of
Island Park

Fresh ingredients, bold signature pies, and a warm mountain-lodge table to gather around — at Blue Buffalo Resort, right on US-20.

Order Online Call · (208) 558-8046
  • Open TodaySee hours below
  • Dine In & TakeoutAt Blue Buffalo Resort
  • 4.8★ on Google550+ resort reviews
On US-20, Island Park
14 mi to Yellowstone
Dough made fresh daily
Late Fri & Sat nights
Friends sharing pizzas around a table at Blue Buffalo Pizzeria in Island Park, Idaho

Family-Run · Island Park, Idaho

A Family Pizzeria Built for Gathering

Blue Buffalo Pizzeria is a family-run spot tucked into Blue Buffalo Resort on the edge of Island Park — made for the moment the day's adventures wind down, after the trail, the lake, or the long drive in from Yellowstone's west entrance.

We make our dough fresh every single day and hand-build every pizza with quality ingredients, baked to a golden, blistered crust. From the loaded 208 Supreme to the surprisingly addictive Pickle Pizza, our menu is made to be shared around a warm table with the people you traveled here with.

As one of the few sit-down spots for pizza in Island Park, we welcome resort guests and highway travelers alike. Pull up a chair — good pizza, big windows, and the kind of mountain views that make dinner feel like part of the trip.

Explore the Menu Find us on US-20 →

How It's Made

From Fresh Dough to Your Box

Dough made fresh daily, hand-built, baked, sliced, and boxed — every pizza, right here in Island Park.

@bluebuffalopizzeria

Follow the Daily Bake

Fresh dough, fresh pies, and the view from our table in Island Park. Tag us when you stop in.

Blue Buffalo Pizzeria storefront at dusk — 'Idaho's Best Pizza' in Island Park Buffalo chicken pizza with peppers and red onion Fresh antipasto salad with salami, olives, tomato and pepperoncini Cozy wood-lodge dining room at Blue Buffalo Pizzeria Loaded supreme pizza fresh from the oven Classic pepperoni pizza at Blue Buffalo Pizzeria
Follow @bluebuffalopizzeria

Loved by Guests

What People Are Saying

4.5 · 110 Google reviews
★★★★★

"The family running the place could not have been friendlier, and the food lived up to the welcome. The Ranchers Chicken Pizza is incredible, and the Oreo sticks are to die for. If you're passing through Island Park, do not miss this spot."

— Jeremy L. · Google review
★★★★★

"Finding a pizza spot where a large group agrees on everything is tough — but this place absolutely nailed it! We ordered classic pepperoni, a hearty meat lovers, and even tried the pickle pizza."

— Matt B. · Google review
★★★★★

"My experience was really great — the pizza was just as yummy as I expected! The gals were super polite when I came in, and Avery took great care of me."

— Alexsis L. · Google review
Write a Review Read all 110 reviews

Good to Know

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Blue Buffalo Pizzeria located?

We're at 3402 US-20 in Island Park, Idaho, inside Blue Buffalo Resort — about 14 miles from Yellowstone's west entrance and easy to reach right off the highway.

Do you make your pizza dough fresh?

Yes. We're a family-run pizzeria and we make our dough fresh every single day for a hand-crafted, golden, blistered crust.

Can I order ahead for takeout?

Absolutely. Order online for pickup, or call us at (208) 558-8046 and we'll have your order hot and ready. We offer both dine-in and takeout.

What are your hours?

Monday–Thursday 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM, Friday & Saturday 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM, and we're closed on Sundays.

Do you have options besides pizza?

Yes — fresh salads, dessert pizzas like Oreo sticks and cinnamon pizza sticks, cheese bread, and a full build-your-own pizza menu.

After the Trail, Before the Fire

Pull Up a Chair

Whether you're staying at the resort or just passing through Island Park, dinner's on us to make great. Order online or call ahead and we'll have it hot and ready.

Order Online Call (208) 558-8046

Visit Us

Find Blue Buffalo Pizzeria

Right on US-20 inside Blue Buffalo Resort — easy to reach whether you're staying the night or just driving through Island Park.

Location

3402 US-20
Island Park, ID 83429
Get Directions →

Order & Questions

(208) 558-8046

Hours

Mon – Thu12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Fri – Sat11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
SundayClosed
Order Online Call to Order