Island Park, Idaho · Minutes from Yellowstone

Hand-Crafted Pizza
in the Heart of
Island Park

Fresh ingredients, bold signature pies, and a warm mountain-lodge table to gather around — at Blue Buffalo Resort, right on US-20.

Call to Order · (208) 558-8046 View the Menu

Open TodaySee hours below
Dine In & TakeoutAt Blue Buffalo Resort
4.7★ on Google550+ resort reviews

On US-20, Island Park

14 mi to Yellowstone

Fresh, made-to-order

Late Fri & Sat nights

Friends sharing pizzas around a table at Blue Buffalo Pizzeria in Island Park, Idaho

Our Story

A Pizzeria Built for Gathering

Tucked into Blue Buffalo Resort on the edge of Island Park, our pizzeria was made for the moment the day's adventures wind down — after the trail, the lake, or the long drive in from Yellowstone's west entrance.

Every pizza is hand-built with fresh ingredients and baked to a golden, blistered crust. From the loaded 208 Supreme to the surprisingly addictive Pickle Pizza, our menu is made to be shared around a warm table with the people you traveled here with.

Whether you're a resort guest or just passing through on the highway, pull up a chair. Good pizza, big windows, and the kind of mountain views that make dinner feel like part of the trip.

Explore the Menu Find us on US-20 →

The Menu

Wide variety, fresh ingredients, cooked to perfection. Call (208) 558-8046 to order ahead.

208 Supreme

$24

Marinara, house cheese, pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onion, olive & mushroom — the loaded local favorite.

Mad Hawaiian

$20

Marinara, house cheese, Canadian bacon, pineapple & jalapeño — sweet heat done right.

Meat Eater

$23

Marinara, house cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage & Canadian bacon — for the serious carnivore.

All Signature Pizzas

208 Supreme$24
Marinara, house cheese, pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onion, olive, mushroom
Mad Hawaiian$20
Marinara, house cheese, Canadian bacon, pineapple, jalapeño
Meat Eater$23
Marinara, house cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon
Special 'T'$24
Marinara, house cheese, pepperoni, salami, pepperoncini, tomato, onion, hot honey
Ranchers Chicken$22
Ranch base, house cheese, chicken, bacon, onion, tomato
Mediterranean$23
Sundried tomatoes, feta, spinach, chicken, red onion, garlic butter, balsamic glaze
Pickle Pizza$19
Marinara, house cheese, pepperoni, pickle, hot honey
Veggie Pizza$21
Marinara, peppers, mushroom, onion, olive, tomato, hot honey
BBQ Pizza$22
BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, onion, peppers